The Difference Between Understanding and Knowing the Times Tables

A child can know that 7 × 8 = 56 without knowing what it means, and a child can understand multiplication perfectly well and still need ten seconds to find 7 × 8. Both situations are common in 3rd and 4th grade, and both cause trouble later.
Parents often hear strong opinions on which matters more. Four common beliefs about understanding and memorizing deserve a closer look, and a sensible order for practice at home follows from them.
Myth: Understanding Makes Memorizing Unnecessary
The idea goes like this: if a child really understands multiplication, they can always work out the answer, so why memorize? If a child knows that 7 × 8 is seven groups of eight, they can count, add, or split the problem every time.
The trouble is time and attention. Working out 7 × 8 from scratch takes steps, and each step uses up mental space that a bigger problem needs.
In 4th grade, multiplying 47 × 8 involves several single-digit facts. Building each one from scratch, a student can lose the thread halfway through.
That is why the Common Core asks for both.
It wants 3rd graders to understand a product such as 5 × 7 as five groups of seven, and it also wants every single-digit fact to come without effort by the end of the year. Understanding is the start, not a replacement for remembering.
Myth: Memorizing Is Enough on Its Own
The opposite belief is common too. Drill the facts, the thinking goes, and the meaning will take care of itself. Plenty of adults learned that way and turned out fine.
Research suggests that something is lost, though. A study of 3rd graders compared a traditional program focused on memorizing the facts with one that focused on number sense and the meaning of operations.
Children in the memorization-focused classes showed much less understanding of basic multiplication ideas, such as how multiplication relates to addition.
Teacher educators who write about fact fluency hear a telling story from adults. Some say they can find any fact quickly, but only after singing the song that goes with it.
Others use a finger trick for the 9s with no idea why it works. They remember answers, but they cannot reason about them.
A memorized fact with no meaning behind it is fragile. When it slips, there is nothing to rebuild it from.
Knowing that 6 × 7 is six groups of seven, a child can get back to 42 from five sevens, which make 35, plus one more seven. Someone who only memorized 42 is stuck.
Myth: One Must Be Finished Before the Other Starts
A common view is that understanding must be complete before any memorizing begins. Another view says the reverse. Both assume the two happen one after the other.
A 2015 review of research on math learning looked at exactly this. It found that the two kinds of knowledge support each other in both directions: understanding helps children learn procedures and facts, and practicing them helps understanding grow.
The authors also noted that very few studies have compared teaching one first with teaching the other first, so there is little evidence for a strict order.
In practice, they grow together. Right after learning what 3 × 4 means, a child can start remembering it, and each time they recall it, the meaning gets a little firmer.
Myth: Speed Proves Understanding
A fast answer feels like proof that a child has mastered a fact. Sometimes it is. But speed can come from a memorized sound pattern just as easily as from real knowledge.
One study with 58 fourth graders is useful here. One group practiced with timed drills only. The other also learned ways of thinking about the facts. Both groups became quick at the facts.
But the group that combined thinking strategies with practice did better on tasks that asked them to use the facts, such as working with bigger numbers or estimating.
So a fast answer to 6 × 8 is good news, but it is not the whole picture. A quick extra question tells you more: "How could you show 6 × 8 with a drawing?" or "If 6 × 8 is 48, what is 6 × 9?"
Answering both with ease means knowing the fact in two ways. Hesitating on the follow-up means the answer is there but not yet the meaning behind it, and a few drawings will help.
A Sensible Order at Home
Because the two grow together, the best plan weaves them. For each new table, a reasonable rhythm looks like this.
Start with meaning for a few days. Draw the facts as equal groups or rows. Build them with coins or blocks. Tell short stories that match them, like 4 bags with 6 apples each. Your child should be able to show any fact from the table before you focus on speed.
Then move to remembering. Write the facts from memory and check them. Say them aloud. Practice briefly and often, first in order, then mixed with tables your child already knows. A quiz on a times table page, such as the 6s, fits well at this stage.
Keep going back to meaning now and then. When a fact keeps slipping, draw it again. When your child answers quickly, ask how they know. Each return trip makes the fact sturdier.
What if your child is older and already memorized the facts without the meaning? There is no need to start over. Pick a few facts and ask your child to draw them, build them, or turn them into a short story. Many kids pick up the meaning quickly once they have the answers, and the drawing gives them a way back when a fact slips.
And what if your child understands everything but is slow? Then the meaning is in place, and the job now is regular recall. Short daily practice with mixed facts, plus a small list of the slowest ones, is often what moves a child from working it out to simply knowing.
The goal is a child who knows 7 × 8 = 56 in a second, and who can also explain where 56 comes from. That combination is what carries a child through division, fractions, and multi-digit multiplication in the grades ahead.
Related articles
- The Concrete-Representational-Abstract Method
- The Complete Guide to Times Tables: Everything Parents Should Know
- What Fact Fluency Really Means: Accuracy, Flexibility, and Speed
- Explaining Multiplication to Your Child: The Right Language
- Earning the Times Tables Certificate: Working Toward Bronze, Silver, and Gold
